SAC126 - DNSSEC Delegation Signer (DS) Record Automation
Abstract
The deployment of Domain Name System (DNS) Security Extensions (DNSSEC) has been
hindered by a number of obstacles. This report focuses on one: the management of Delegation
Signer (DS) records, which connect a child zone’s DNSSEC public key and signatures to the
chain of trust provided by its parent zone (e.g., a zone corresponding to a top-level domain).
DNSSEC is not simply enabled by signing a delegated domain’s DNS zone with DNSSEC
signatures. It is also necessary to configure (and later maintain) appropriate DS records, which
involves coordinated actions by the DNS operator, registrant, registrar, and registry.
In the case where the domain’s DNS service is operated by the registrar, this process can be
reduced to a simple internal operation by the registrar. If the functions are separated, this is not
possible. This report is therefore focused on when the domain’s DNS service is not operated by
the registrar, but by a third-party DNS operator.
In such a scenario, current practice holds the registrant responsible for coordinating DS
maintenance. The registrant (or someone appointed by them) needs to first obtain DNSSEC
public key parameters from the DNS operator, and convey these parameters to the registrar
(potentially via a reseller). The registrar will then need to relay these DNSSEC public key
parameters to the registry, who will use them to create and publish the DS record in the parent
zone. This process often involves idiosyncratic interfaces for each combination of DNS operator
and registrar, requiring a level of engagement and time investment, awareness, and
understanding that often do not match with what the registrant knows or expects. The complexity of the process further introduces opportunity for error.
This can be alleviated by employing automation for the data exchanges required for DS
maintenance so that, when the domain’s DNS service is operated by a third party, registries or
registrars can, without human involvement, obtain all information needed for keeping DS records up to date. Various approaches to achieve this are possible, such as a scheme where the registry or registrar actively contacts the Child DNS operator, or vice versa. The different approaches come with different challenges with respect to authentication, timing, and efficiency.
The IETF has standardized specifications around the first approach, where the parent pulls
information from the Child DNS operator, and operational experience has been gained over
recent years. However, some standardization gaps remain (such as to improve efficiency and
error handling). In addition, the industry could benefit from further development of best practices in deploying the technology.
The SSAC believes that automated DS maintenance should be a goal for the domain name
industry. To make this a reality, the SSAC makes several recommendations with the goal to spur
industry players and ICANN towards an industry best practice for DNSSEC DS automation.
hindered by a number of obstacles. This report focuses on one: the management of Delegation
Signer (DS) records, which connect a child zone’s DNSSEC public key and signatures to the
chain of trust provided by its parent zone (e.g., a zone corresponding to a top-level domain).
DNSSEC is not simply enabled by signing a delegated domain’s DNS zone with DNSSEC
signatures. It is also necessary to configure (and later maintain) appropriate DS records, which
involves coordinated actions by the DNS operator, registrant, registrar, and registry.
In the case where the domain’s DNS service is operated by the registrar, this process can be
reduced to a simple internal operation by the registrar. If the functions are separated, this is not
possible. This report is therefore focused on when the domain’s DNS service is not operated by
the registrar, but by a third-party DNS operator.
In such a scenario, current practice holds the registrant responsible for coordinating DS
maintenance. The registrant (or someone appointed by them) needs to first obtain DNSSEC
public key parameters from the DNS operator, and convey these parameters to the registrar
(potentially via a reseller). The registrar will then need to relay these DNSSEC public key
parameters to the registry, who will use them to create and publish the DS record in the parent
zone. This process often involves idiosyncratic interfaces for each combination of DNS operator
and registrar, requiring a level of engagement and time investment, awareness, and
understanding that often do not match with what the registrant knows or expects. The complexity of the process further introduces opportunity for error.
This can be alleviated by employing automation for the data exchanges required for DS
maintenance so that, when the domain’s DNS service is operated by a third party, registries or
registrars can, without human involvement, obtain all information needed for keeping DS records up to date. Various approaches to achieve this are possible, such as a scheme where the registry or registrar actively contacts the Child DNS operator, or vice versa. The different approaches come with different challenges with respect to authentication, timing, and efficiency.
The IETF has standardized specifications around the first approach, where the parent pulls
information from the Child DNS operator, and operational experience has been gained over
recent years. However, some standardization gaps remain (such as to improve efficiency and
error handling). In addition, the industry could benefit from further development of best practices in deploying the technology.
The SSAC believes that automated DS maintenance should be a goal for the domain name
industry. To make this a reality, the SSAC makes several recommendations with the goal to spur
industry players and ICANN towards an industry best practice for DNSSEC DS automation.
Research Areas
