AI-assisted Assessment of Coding Practices in Industrial Code Review

Ivan Budiselic
Malgorzata (Gosia) Salawa
Juanjo Carin
Jovan Andonov
Mateusz Lewko
Rene Just

Abstract

Modern code review is a process in which incremental code contributions made by one software developer are reviewed by one or more peers before it is committed to the version control system. An important element of modern code review is verifying that the code under review adheres to style guidelines and best practices of the corresponding programming language. Some of these rules are universal and can be checked automatically or enforced via code formatters. Other rules, however, are context-dependent and the corresponding checks are commonly left to developers who are experts in the given programming language and whose time is expensive. Many automated systems have been developed that attempt to detect various rule violations without any human intervention. Historically, such systems implement targeted analyses and were themselves expensive to develop. This paper presents AutoCommenter, a system that uses a state of the art large language model to automatically learn and enforce programming language best practices. We implemented AutoCommenter for four programming languages: C++, Java, Python and Go. We evaluated its performance and adoption in a large industrial setting. Our evaluation shows that a model that automatically learns language best practices is feasible and has a measurable positive impact on the developer workflow. Additionally, we present the challenges we faced when deploying such a model to tens of thousands of developers and provide lessons we learned for any practitioners that would like to replicate the work or build on top of it.

Research Areas