Jump to Content

Bayesian approach to determining penetrance of pathogenic SDH variants

Diana E Benn
Ying Zhu
Katrina A Andrews
Mathilda Wilding
Emma L Duncan
Trisha Dwight
Richard W Tothill
John Burgess
Ashley Crook
Anthony J Gill
Rodney J Hicks
Edward Kim
Catherine Luxford
Helen Marfan
Anne Louise Richardson
Bruce Robinson
Arran Schlosberg
Rachel Susman
Lyndal Tacon
Alison Trainer
Katherine Tucker
Eamonn R Maher
Michael Field
Roderick J Clifton-Bligh
Journal of Medical Genetics, vol. 55 (2019)


Background Until recently, determining penetrance required large observational cohort studies. Data from the Exome Aggregate Consortium (ExAC) allows a Bayesian approach to calculate penetrance, in that population frequencies of pathogenic germline variants should be inversely proportional to their penetrance for disease. We tested this hypothesis using data from two cohorts for succinate dehydrogenase subunits A, B and C (SDHA–C) genetic variants associated with hereditary pheochromocytoma/paraganglioma (PC/PGL). Methods Two cohorts were 575 unrelated Australian subjects and 1240 unrelated UK subjects, respectively, with PC/PGL in whom genetic testing had been performed. Penetrance of pathogenic SDHA–C variants was calculated by comparing allelic frequencies in cases versus controls from ExAC (removing those variants contributed by The Cancer Genome Atlas). Results Pathogenic SDHA–C variants were identified in 106 subjects (18.4%) in cohort 1 and 317 subjects (25.6%) in cohort 2. Of 94 different pathogenic variants from both cohorts (seven in SDHA, 75 in SDHB and 12 in SDHC), 13 are reported in ExAC (two in SDHA, nine in SDHB and two in SDHC) accounting for 21% of subjects with SDHA–C variants. Combining data from both cohorts, estimated lifetime disease penetrance was 22.0% (95% CI 15.2% to 30.9%) for SDHB variants, 8.3% (95% CI 3.5% to 18.5%) for SDHC variants and 1.7% (95% CI 0.8% to 3.8%) for SDHA variants. Conclusion Pathogenic variants in SDHB are more penetrant than those in SDHC and SDHA. Our findings have important implications for counselling and surveillance of subjects carrying these pathogenic variants.

Research Areas